[{"judge":"opus","outcome":"completed","diagnostics":[],"output":{"features":[{"name":"bar","scores":[2,null,2,1,2,null,2,2,null,null,null,2,2,2,2],"issues":[{"principle":4,"severity":"minor","evidence":"idle-awake.png, tasks-chip-tooltip.png (chips 'clip', 'bright', 'notify', 'launch'; tooltip reveals 'clipboard')","problem":"Horizontal chip labels are clipped abbreviations or the wrong part of speech ('notify' is a verb, 'bright' an adjective), not plain nouns.","fix":"Use short plain nouns that fit the compact chip, such as 'clipboard' or 'clips', 'brightness' or 'light', 'alerts', 'apps', and keep the tooltips as they are."}]},{"name":"clock","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,null,null,2,1,2,2,2],"issues":[{"principle":12,"severity":"minor","evidence":"clock-setup.png vs vault-setup.png","problem":"The calendar setup form uses only placeholders, so field names disappear once typed, while the vault setup form has persistent labels and a compact save button.","fix":"Reuse the vault/SetupField pattern: persistent lowercase labels above each field and the same save button sizing."}]},{"name":"launcher","scores":[null,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,null,null,2,2,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"media","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,null,null,2,2,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"noko","scores":[1,2,2,1,2,2,2,2,null,2,2,2,1,2,null],"issues":[{"principle":13,"severity":"major","evidence":"noko-capture-busy-chip.png","problem":"The 'capturing' focus overlay pill is drawn on top of the open popup, covering the area between its status line and the stop capture button and repeating 'capturing' twice.","fix":"Hide or offset the focus overlay while the noko popup is open on that output, so the popup alone shows capture state."},{"principle":1,"severity":"minor","evidence":"noko-blocked-chip.png, shell-loaded.png","problem":"A not-yet-installed optional feature keeps the chip in strong emphasis on every glance, equal to real problems like system or network.","fix":"Show setup-needed as the '!' mark (like system's dot level) and reserve strong emphasis for a failed capture or blocked active work."},{"principle":4,"severity":"minor","evidence":"noko-blocked.png ('install setup')","problem":"'install setup' is an unclear verb phrase for installing the missing speech parts.","fix":"Label the button 'install' or 'set up' and keep the missing items listed below it."}]},{"name":"system","scores":[2,1,2,1,2,2,2,2,null,null,2,2,1,2,2],"issues":[{"principle":2,"severity":"minor","evidence":"shell-system.png, system-agent-eligibility.png","problem":"The live metrics block leads the popup and pushes 'needs attention', the reason the chip lit up, below the fold.","fix":"When problems exist, place 'needs attention' first and collapse the live block behind its disclosure."},{"principle":4,"severity":"minor","evidence":"system-all-clear.png, shell-system.png ('current boot · last 24 hours · latest 100 · not every app exit leaves a record', '24.05 on 12 cores', '200% busy')","problem":"The scope line is long filler and the load wording is jargon.","fix":"Shorten the scope line to 'last 24 hours' and phrase load in plain words, such as 'cpu overloaded'."},{"principle":13,"severity":"minor","evidence":"system-incident-details.png","problem":"Expanding an incident leaves its new detail and error line cut off at the viewport bottom instead of scrolling it into view.","fix":"Scroll the expanded incident fully into view (ensureVisible) on expansion."}]},{"name":"clipboard","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,2,2,null,null,null,2,2,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"vault","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,2,2,null,null,null,2,2,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"audio","scores":[2,2,2,2,1,2,2,2,null,null,2,2,2,2,null],"issues":[{"principle":5,"severity":"minor","evidence":"audio-drag-update.png (128%)","problem":"Volume above 100% looks the same as normal volume, so amplification beyond the device level is not flagged.","fix":"Above 100%, tint the percentage with the warning role and add a short 'boosted' label."}]},{"name":"brightness","scores":[null,2,2,1,1,2,1,2,null,null,2,2,2,2,null],"issues":[{"principle":5,"severity":"major","evidence":"brightness-cancelled.png ('find monitors · failed · cancelled' with red error mark)","problem":"A user cancellation is shown as a failure with the error icon and colour, so cancelled and failed look the same.","fix":"Give cancelled steps a neutral 'stopped' mark and the text 'cancelled' only, and keep red ✕ for real failures."},{"principle":7,"severity":"major","evidence":"brightness-authorization.png, brightness-detection.png, brightness-installation.png","problem":"The 'setup ddc' tooltip stays over the first setup steps while setup runs and hides progress (see shared).","fix":"Hide the tooltip once the button is pressed or disabled, and place it so it never covers the step list."},{"principle":4,"severity":"minor","evidence":"brightness-adaptive-ready.png ('ddc ready')","problem":"The disclosure label repeats the 'ddc' acronym beyond the spec-explicit 'setup ddc' button.","fix":"Label the disclosure 'monitor control' and keep 'setup ddc' only on the button the spec names."}]},{"name":"connectivity","scores":[2,1,2,2,2,2,1,null,2,null,2,2,2,2,null],"issues":[{"principle":2,"severity":"minor","evidence":"connectivity-bluetooth-devices.png","problem":"Each device row always shows two badges, a battery level and three icon-only secondary actions (trust, block, forget), unlike wireless rows, which disclose details on expand.","fix":"Move trust, block and forget behind the row's expand disclosure, like wireless, and keep connect/disconnect as the row action."},{"principle":7,"severity":"minor","evidence":"connectivity-join-next-step.png, connectivity-offline.png, connectivity-masked-update.png","problem":"The bluetooth toggle tooltip covers the 'no devices' title, and the 'collapse fixture-secure' tooltip sits over a different row (see shared).","fix":"Apply the shared tooltip placement fix."}]},{"name":"power","scores":[2,2,2,2,1,2,2,null,2,null,2,2,2,2,null],"issues":[{"principle":5,"severity":"minor","evidence":"power-battery-critical-open.png","problem":"At 7% the popup shows only a red sliver and 'discharging', with no word saying the battery is critical or what to do.","fix":"Below the critical threshold, add 'battery critical · plug in' under the percentage in the warning role."}]},{"name":"notifications","scores":[2,1,2,2,2,2,2,null,null,2,2,2,2,1,null],"issues":[{"principle":2,"severity":"minor","evidence":"notifications-clear-armed.png","problem":"While clear all is armed, two red 'clear all' buttons are visible (header and confirmation), which breaks the one-destructive-action rule.","fix":"Hide or neutralise the header 'clear all' while its confirmation is shown."},{"principle":14,"severity":"minor","evidence":"notifications-do-not-disturb.png vs notifications-history.png","problem":"In the popup, do not disturb on differs from off only by the bell-slash glyph; the border seen is the focus ring, not a checked style.","fix":"Give the active toggle the shared checked style (accent tint and border, as the 'wireless' toggle has) in addition to the icon."}]},{"name":"tray","scores":[1,2,2,2,2,2,2,null,null,null,2,2,2,2,null],"issues":[{"principle":1,"severity":"minor","evidence":"tray-populated.png ('tray 1') vs shell-tray.png ('tray')","problem":"The chip label adds a count, so its width changes whenever an app adds or removes a tray item, a routine update.","fix":"Drop the count from the label and keep the '!' mark for items that need attention."}]},{"name":"osd","scores":[null,2,2,1,2,null,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,2,null],"issues":[{"principle":4,"severity":"minor","evidence":"osd-unknown-event.png ('bogus' / 'unknown', error styling)","problem":"An unknown event shows its raw identifier to the user as a red error, which is jargon with no meaning or next step.","fix":"Log unknown events to diagnostics and do not show an OSD, or show a generic 'unsupported action'."}]},{"name":"privilege","scores":[null,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,null,null,2,2,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"screenshots","scores":[null,null,null,2,2,null,null,null,null,2,2,null,null,null,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"shared","scores":[null,null,2,null,null,2,1,2,null,null,null,2,2,2,null],"issues":[{"principle":7,"severity":"major","evidence":"PopupToolTip.qml:22-23 (always centred below parent); brightness-installation.png, connectivity-offline.png, connectivity-masked-update.png","problem":"Popup tooltips drop directly below their control and stay open after activation or on a disabled control, covering the neighbouring content the user is reading, and row tooltips can land over another row.","fix":"Close tooltips on press or disable, and flip or offset placement so they avoid sibling content (above for list rows, beside for full-width buttons)."}]}],"counterexample":"Most of my keyboard (6) and dismissal (9) passes rest on visible focus rings in the screenshots and on suite check names (power and connectivity disarm on outside, switch and Escape), not on traversing every control. A full Tab traversal could still find unreachable icon actions. Equally, system's metrics-first order could be judged correct if the owner sees live monitoring as that popup's primary task, which would lift system 2 to a pass.","uncertainty":"The source path in the brief (/tmp/nuguland-zen) does not exist, so I checked code on the trunk checkout (812d7eb5), which may differ slightly from the code behind the r3 screenshots. I did not penalise the horizontal bar for using text chips rather than icon-led ones, because the owner may intend it. Toast rendering and OSD motion have no screenshots, so I left those scores null or based them only on source."}},{"judge":"gpt","outcome":"completed","diagnostics":[],"output":{"features":[{"name":"screenshots","scores":[null,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,2,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"privilege","scores":[null,2,2,2,2,2,2,null,null,2,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"osd","scores":[null,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,null,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"tray","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,2,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"notifications","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,2,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"power","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"connectivity","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"brightness","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"audio","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,2,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"vault","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,2,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"clipboard","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"system","scores":[2,2,2,1,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[{"principle":4,"severity":"minor","evidence":"r3/system/system-agent-eligibility.png","problem":"The action tooltip “open 3 updates available” exceeds three words and reads like a status label appended to a verb.","fix":"Use “open updates” while retaining the count in the row."}]},{"name":"noko","scores":[2,2,2,1,2,null,2,null,null,2,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[{"principle":4,"severity":"minor","evidence":"r3/noko/noko-blocked.png; r3/noko/shell-noko.png","problem":"“install setup” and “install setup before recording” obscure what will actually be installed.","fix":"Use “install dictation” with “install speech tools before recording” as explanatory text."}]},{"name":"media","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"launcher","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,2,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"clock","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"bar","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"shared","scores":[null,2,2,2,2,2,1,null,2,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[{"principle":7,"severity":"major","evidence":"r3/brightness/brightness-authorization.png; r3/brightness/brightness-detection.png; r3/connectivity/connectivity-offline.png","problem":"Shared tooltips still cover task information, hiding setup stages in brightness and the empty-device message in connectivity.","fix":"Suppress redundant labeled-control tooltips and place necessary tooltips outside adjacent status content."}]}],"counterexample":"r3/noko/noko-setup.png and r3/power/power-hover.png demonstrate successful tooltip suppression without hiding actions; the remaining occlusion is localized, not universal.","uncertainty":"Opened every supplied feature screenshot and inspected corresponding nested-run assertion and runner logs. Both the brief’s source root /tmp/nuguland-zen and the runs’ recorded root /tmp/nuguland-zen-int are absent. Nulls denote properties not established by those artifacts, including complete keyboard coverage where incomplete, motion deadlines, production hidden work, some retention paths, and exhaustive tooltip/accessibility contracts. Reviewed geometry is 1280×720; numerical contrast and other target resolutions remain unverified. Explicit arrrgh and setup ddc precedence exceptions were preserved."}}]