repositories / dotfiles
dotfiles
bugabingas dorkfiles
owned by admin
quickshell/nuguland/.system/specs/NL-SPEC-VQXGUHYK-zen-of-nugu/evidence/r2-judgements.json
Raw[{"judge":"opus","outcome":"completed","diagnostics":[],"output":{"features":[{"name":"bar","scores":[2,null,2,1,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,2,2,2,2],"issues":[{"principle":4,"severity":"minor","evidence":"idle-awake.png, tasks-end-slot-right.png: horizontal labels 'launch', 'clip', 'bright', 'notify'","problem":"Several chip labels are clipped words or the wrong part of speech ('bright' is an adjective, 'notify' a verb) instead of short plain nouns.","fix":"Use short lowercase nouns that fit the same width, e.g. 'light' for brightness and 'alerts' for notifications, and keep the tooltips as the full names."}]},{"name":"clock","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,null,2,2,2,2,2,2],"issues":[]},{"name":"launcher","scores":[2,2,1,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2],"issues":[{"principle":3,"severity":"minor","evidence":"launcher-apps.png, shell-launcher.png: detail header 'fixture termi…' / 'AMDGPU TO…' plus a monospace subtitle, next to the same selected row","problem":"The detail pane repeats the selected row's name and subtitle, and in its narrow header almost every real app name gets cut off.","fix":"Drop the repeated title block from the detail pane and keep only the icon plus the actions, or let the name wrap to two lines in the theme's body font."}]},{"name":"media","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,null,2,2,2,2,2,2],"issues":[]},{"name":"noko","scores":[2,1,1,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,1,2,2,2],"issues":[{"principle":2,"severity":"minor","evidence":"noko-blocked.png: 'install setup' primary button above a full-width primary-tinted disabled 'start capture'","problem":"Two primary-styled actions are visible at once, and the disabled one's purple-on-purple label is barely readable.","fix":"Render 'start capture' as a neutral disabled button while setup is needed, so 'install setup' is the only primary."},{"principle":3,"severity":"minor","evidence":"noko-open.png: 'last transcripts' heading in accent colour; a whole status card holds only the word 'ready'","problem":"The accent colour goes to a section heading that has no state, and a card is spent on a routine 'ready'.","fix":"Use the neutral title style for 'last transcripts' and show 'ready' as inline meta text, keeping the card for setup or failure states."},{"principle":12,"severity":"minor","evidence":"shell-loaded.png / noko-blocked-chip.png: 'noko!' vs 'system' with a superscript badge; Noko.qml:32","problem":"Noko puts the '!' inside its label while other chips mark attention with the shared badge, so the same state looks different.","fix":"Keep the label 'noko' and signal blocked through barStrong plus the shared attention badge, like system and power."}]},{"name":"system","scores":[2,1,2,1,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2],"issues":[{"principle":2,"severity":"major","evidence":"system-populated.png, system-machine.png, system-incidents.png: the 'machine' disclosure and the 'live' metrics fill the top; 'needs attention' starts at y≈420 and its cards scroll off","problem":"The popup's primary task (what needs attention) comes after secondary telemetry, so a failing service is below the fold whenever machine details are open.","fix":"Put 'needs attention' (or the 'all ok' line) first and move 'live' and 'machine' below it as secondary sections."},{"principle":4,"severity":"minor","evidence":"system-populated.png: 'mem', 'load 0.50 · 0.30 · 0.20', 'signal sigsegv · pid 123 · uid 1000'","problem":"The metric labels and crash details use abbreviations and kernel jargon where plain words exist.","fix":"Say 'memory', show load as one '% busy' figure with the triple in the tooltip, and move signal, pid and uid behind the incident details disclosure."}]},{"name":"clipboard","scores":[1,2,2,1,2,2,1,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2],"issues":[{"principle":1,"severity":"minor","evidence":"clipboard-private-chip.png: paused capture shows only a pink dot on 'clip', the same dot media and notify use for activity","problem":"Paused capture looks like ordinary activity on the chip, so a forgotten pause cannot be read at a glance.","fix":"Give the paused state its own chip mark (the eye-off glyph in the vertical bar, a distinct badge in the horizontal bar) instead of the activity dot."},{"principle":4,"severity":"minor","evidence":"ClipboardPanel.qml:491 tooltip 'remove selected item from clipboard history'","problem":"The delete tooltip is six words, against the three-word limit for actions.","fix":"Make the tooltip match the accessible name: 'delete selected item'."},{"principle":7,"severity":"minor","evidence":"clipboard-paste-pending.png vs clipboard-filtered.png: 'pasting…' widens the paste button and moves copy, pin and delete 24 px to the right","problem":"The action row moves under the pointer while a paste is pending, so a second click can land on the wrong action.","fix":"Give the paste button a fixed width that fits both 'paste' and 'pasting…'."}]},{"name":"vault","scores":[2,2,2,1,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2],"issues":[{"principle":4,"severity":"minor","evidence":"shell-vault.png 'server url'; vault-locked.png 'encrypted cache ready'","problem":"Setup and lock wording uses an acronym and implementation jargon where plain words exist.","fix":"Use 'server address' and 'offline copy ready' (or omit that line)."}]},{"name":"audio","scores":[1,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,1,2,2,2,2,2],"issues":[{"principle":1,"severity":"minor","evidence":"audio-privacy-chip.png: the chip label changes from 'audio' to 'mic'; Registry.qml:315","problem":"The chip swaps its name for the privacy state, so its identity and width change when the microphone opens.","fix":"Keep 'audio' as the label and show mic or camera use as a dot or badge plus the tooltip, as the vertical bar's icon already does."},{"principle":10,"severity":"minor","evidence":"AudioPanel.qml:24,199 → Audio.qml:406,416 call osd() on every slider move and mute toggle","problem":"Dragging a slider in the open popup also pops the volume OSD, repeating a value the popup already shows.","fix":"Pass a quiet flag from the panel path, as Media.qml already does, so only keys and IPC show the OSD."}]},{"name":"brightness","scores":[2,2,2,1,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,1,2,2],"issues":[{"principle":4,"severity":"minor","evidence":"brightness-ready-expanded.png: 'ddc ready' expands to 'preflight: done … verification: done … ready: done'","problem":"The disclosure is a seven-line pipeline log in internal jargon that tells the user nothing they can act on.","fix":"Collapse it to one line such as 'monitor control ready', and show stage names only for a stage that failed (the 'setup ddc' label stays per the spec)."},{"principle":13,"severity":"minor","evidence":"brightness-threshold-editor.png: the threshold field shows 'nvalid' (first letter scrolled off)","problem":"The threshold field is too narrow for its own content, so typed text clips.","fix":"Size the field from its font metrics for the longest valid value plus padding, or clamp input to digits so invalid text cannot overflow."}]},{"name":"connectivity","scores":[2,2,2,1,2,2,1,2,1,2,2,2,2,2,2],"issues":[{"principle":9,"severity":"major","evidence":"ConnectivityPanel.qml:771-780 trash icon and :784-793 middle click call bluetoothAction('forget') at once","problem":"Forgetting a paired device is irreversible but acts on one click with no confirmation, so re-pairing is the only way back.","fix":"Arm 'forget device' with an inline confirm that cancels on dismissal, like power's armed reboot."},{"principle":7,"severity":"minor","evidence":"ConnectivityPanel.qml:784-793: middle click forgets, right click toggles block/trust anywhere on the row","problem":"Destructive and trust actions hide behind invisible mouse gestures on the whole row.","fix":"Remove the middle-click forget and keep the gestures only for actions that are also visible buttons."},{"principle":4,"severity":"minor","evidence":"connectivity-bluetooth-devices.png: wifi says 'connected', bluetooth says 'linked'; the trusted device's icon action is 'block device'","problem":"The same state has two words, and the opposite of 'trusted' is shown as the stronger 'block'.","fix":"Use 'connected' in both lists and make the toggle 'untrust device', keeping block behind the device menu."}]},{"name":"power","scores":[2,2,2,1,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,1,2],"issues":[{"principle":4,"severity":"minor","evidence":"power-compact.png 'logout'; power-arrow-focus.png tooltip 'log out now'; power-desktop.png tooltip 'reboot the computer'","problem":"One action label is a noun among verbs, and the tooltips only repeat the labels.","fix":"Label the tile 'log out' and drop the tooltips that repeat a visible, uncut label."},{"principle":14,"severity":"minor","evidence":"power-devices.png: device names 'fixture mouse', 'fixture keyboard' in dim grey on the card","problem":"The device battery names are rendered in a muted tone that looks below 4.5:1 and reads as disabled.","fix":"Use the theme's body text colour for device names and keep muted only for secondary meta."}]},{"name":"notifications","scores":[1,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,1,2,2,2,2,2,2],"issues":[{"principle":9,"severity":"major","evidence":"NotificationGroup.qml:76-83 'clear all' calls discardAllNotifications() on one click; notifications-history.png","problem":"One click on 'clear all' discards the whole history with no confirmation or undo.","fix":"Arm 'clear all' with an inline confirm that cancels on dismissal, or offer a short undo in the panel."},{"principle":1,"severity":"minor","evidence":"notifications-do-not-disturb.png: DND on, but the 'notify' chip looks the same as with DND off","problem":"Active do-not-disturb hides toasts but is invisible on the bar, so a forgotten DND silently swallows alerts.","fix":"Show DND on the chip with a distinct mark (the crossed-bell glyph or a badge), like the idle emphasis rule."}]},{"name":"tray","scores":[2,2,2,1,2,2,2,2,null,2,2,2,2,2,2],"issues":[{"principle":4,"severity":"minor","evidence":"tray-populated.png lightning button; TrayPanel.qml:184-185 tooltip 'secondary action'","problem":"The second icon action and its tooltip use protocol jargon and say nothing about what will happen.","fix":"Name it after the item ('middle click {title}') or hide the button when the item exposes no secondary activation."}]},{"name":"osd","scores":[null,2,2,1,2,null,null,2,null,2,2,2,2,2,2],"issues":[{"principle":4,"severity":"minor","evidence":"osd-long-message.png, shell-screenshot-not-taken-osd.png, osd-unknown-event.png: every failure is titled 'error'","problem":"The heading is a generic word that names neither the subject nor the problem.","fix":"Title error OSDs by subject ('screenshot', 'volume') and keep the failure sentence as the body."}]},{"name":"privilege","scores":[null,2,2,2,1,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2,2],"issues":[{"principle":5,"severity":"minor","evidence":"privilege-checking.png: field shows the empty placeholder, plus 'checking password' and a 'checking…' button","problem":"While checking, the field looks empty as if the password was lost, and the pending state is said twice.","fix":"Keep the masked dots visible and read-only while checking, and show the pending state once, on the button."}]},{"name":"screenshots","scores":[null,null,2,1,2,null,null,2,null,2,2,2,2,2,2],"issues":[{"principle":4,"severity":"minor","evidence":"shell-screenshot-notice.png / shell-screenshot-not-taken-osd.png: 'screenshot not taken · give it a file path'","problem":"The next step tells the user to give 'it' a file path without saying what or where, so the failure cannot be acted on.","fix":"Name the fix plainly, e.g. 'no save folder set · set screenshot-path in niri config'."}]},{"name":"shared","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,1,1,2,2,2,2,1,2,2,2],"issues":[{"principle":12,"severity":"major","evidence":"radius 2.5/4/8/9/12/14/15/18 and literal font families and sizes: VaultPanel.qml:310,432,583; LauncherPanel.qml:307,428; OsdPanel.qml:35,62,88,137; MediaPanel.qml:142","problem":"Panels hard-code radii, fonts and sizes instead of using the Theme scale, so there is no single radius family per surface level.","fix":"Add theme radius tokens per surface level (card, control, icon tile) and type tokens, then replace the literals."},{"principle":7,"severity":"minor","evidence":"noko-setup.png: the 'collapse setup' tooltip covers 'speech engine'; connectivity-masked-update.png: the 'collapse fixture-secure' tooltip covers the expanded row; PopupButton.qml:169","problem":"A disclosure's tooltip, shown on hover or keyboard focus, covers the content the disclosure just revealed.","fix":"Hide the tooltip once a disclosure toggles, or place it on the side away from the revealed content."},{"principle":6,"severity":"minor","evidence":"audio-keyboard-scroll.png: focus on output 8's slider is a faint ring on the knob, while the hovered row 1 is highlighted more strongly","problem":"The slider's keyboard focus is less visible than the pointer hover state, so keyboard users lose their place.","fix":"Give a focused PopupSlider the same 2 px focus border on its row or track that buttons use."}]}],"counterexample":"Strongest case against my mostly-passing verdict: system's zen 2 could fairly be 0, not 1. With the machine disclosure open (system-machine.png), 'needs attention' sits at the bottom edge and its failure card is clipped, so the popup leads with telemetry. Likewise, notifications 'clear all' and bluetooth 'forget device' are one-click irreversible discards that a strict reading of zen 9 would score 0.","uncertainty":"The source path in the brief (/tmp/nuguland-zen) no longer exists. I read source from trunk of /home/me/Workspace/dotfiles/quickshell/nuguland, which carries the r2 fix commits but may differ slightly from the code that produced the r2 screenshots. The contrast findings (power device names, slider focus ring) are visual estimates, not measured pixel values. The fixture service doubles may hide production behaviour, notably whether popup slider moves really pop the volume OSD."}},{"judge":"gpt","outcome":"completed","diagnostics":[],"output":{"features":[{"name":"screenshots","scores":[null,2,2,2,2,null,null,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"privilege","scores":[null,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"osd","scores":[null,2,2,2,2,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"tray","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"notifications","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"power","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"connectivity","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"brightness","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"audio","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"vault","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"clipboard","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"system","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,1,null,2,2,null],"issues":[{"principle":11,"severity":"major","evidence":"/tmp/nl-zen/r2/system/system-agent-unavailable.png; system-incidents.png","problem":"The repair failure says 'pi or wezterm unavailable in session path' without identifying the missing tool or explaining recovery.","fix":"Identify the unavailable tool and provide installation or session-path recovery instructions beside the repair action."}]},{"name":"noko","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"media","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"launcher","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"clock","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"bar","scores":[2,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,null,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]},{"name":"shared","scores":[null,2,2,2,2,null,2,null,null,null,2,null,2,2,null],"issues":[]}],"counterexample":"system-history-unavailable.png supplies explicit recovery instructions plus retry; the recovery shortfall is confined to the repair-tool failure, not system failure states generally.","uncertainty":"Opened every supplied r2 screenshot in the requested feature order. The intended source snapshot /tmp/nuguland-zen/quickshell/nuguland remains missing; no alternate checkout was substituted. Keyboard completeness, focus return, dismissal persistence, motion timing, low-power suppression, interruption policy and hidden polling remain null. Accessible names and complete tooltip coverage remain unverified, hence principle 12 is null. Geometry scores cover supplied 1280×720 renderings only; contrast was reviewed visually, not measured. Brightness's duplicate global/per-display controls and expanded stage log were not penalized because the supplied fix report identifies explicit feature-spec requirements. This is not full behavioral or acceptance verification."}}]