Luigit
repositories / dotfiles

dotfiles

bugabingas dorkfiles

owned by admin

quickshell/nuguland/.system/specs/NL-SPEC-VQXGUHYK-zen-of-nugu/evidence/r1-judgements.json

Raw
[
  {
    "model": "gpt-6.1-sol",
    "tool": "pipi_output",
    "args": {
      "output": {
        "features": [
          {
            "name": "screenshots",
            "scores": [
              null,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              1,
              null,
              null,
              null,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              null,
              null,
              null,
              2
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 5,
                "severity": "major",
                "evidence": "/tmp/nuguland-zen-int/quickshell/nuguland/Screenshots.qml:194-195,349-365; niri-unconfirmed-history.png",
                "problem": "Unconfirmed captures report uncertainty only through an ephemeral OSD; the displayed history and error text belong to the diagnostic fixture, not a rendered product history surface.",
                "fix": "Retain an actionable notification in notification history, naming the unconfirmed capture and offering to open its folder."
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "privilege",
            "scores": [
              null,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": []
          },
          {
            "name": "osd",
            "scores": [
              null,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              null,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": []
          },
          {
            "name": "tray",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              null,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": []
          },
          {
            "name": "notifications",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              1,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 11,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "notifications-reply-retry.png; /tmp/nuguland-zen-int/quickshell/nuguland/features/notifications/NotificationCard.qml:211-224",
                "problem": "The failed reply preserves its draft but says only 'reply not sent', leaving the Enter-to-retry action undisclosed.",
                "fix": "Add 'press enter to retry' beside the failure, or expose a small retry button."
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "power",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": []
          },
          {
            "name": "connectivity",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": []
          },
          {
            "name": "brightness",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": []
          },
          {
            "name": "audio",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": []
          },
          {
            "name": "vault",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": []
          },
          {
            "name": "clipboard",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              1,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 11,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "clipboard-no-matches.png; shell-clipboard.png",
                "problem": "Empty clipboard and unmatched search states provide no next step, unlike the actionable empty searches in launcher and vault.",
                "fix": "Offer 'clear search' for unmatched queries and explain that copying text populates an empty history."
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "system",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              1,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              1,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 4,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "system-incidents.png; shell-system.png",
                "problem": "Ordinary incident summaries expose unexplained terms such as 'sigsegv', 'pid' and 'oom'.",
                "fix": "Use plain crash and memory-exhaustion summaries, keeping technical identifiers behind incident details."
              },
              {
                "principle": 11,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "system-history-unavailable.png",
                "problem": "Unavailable history names the unreadable journal but offers neither a recovery instruction nor a retry action.",
                "fix": "Add a short journal-access recovery instruction and a retry action."
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "noko",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": []
          },
          {
            "name": "media",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2
            ],
            "issues": []
          },
          {
            "name": "launcher",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": []
          },
          {
            "name": "clock",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              null,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": []
          },
          {
            "name": "bar",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              null,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": []
          },
          {
            "name": "shared",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              1,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              1,
              null
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 6,
                "severity": "major",
                "evidence": "/tmp/nuguland-zen-int/quickshell/nuguland/PopoutHost.qml:196-201,250-259; /tmp/nuguland-ui-test-pNM1p7/assertions.jsonl:2; /tmp/nuguland-ui-test-2hWWzD/assertions.jsonl:2; /tmp/nuguland-ui-test-C5F19I/assertions.jsonl:2",
                "problem": "Ordinary non-search popups initially focus the outer card rather than their primary control; recorded open snapshots contain no focused feature control.",
                "fix": "Provide an explicit primary-focus target through the public panel contract and focus it after the popup becomes active."
              },
              {
                "principle": 14,
                "severity": "major",
                "evidence": "clipboard-history.png; vault-unlocked.png; /tmp/nuguland-zen-int/quickshell/nuguland/PopupCard.qml:23-27",
                "problem": "Selected result cards distinguish selection through a tinted fill alone when keyboard focus remains in the search field.",
                "fix": "Add a non-colour selection marker, such as a check or shaped selection rail, to shared selectable cards."
              }
            ]
          }
        ],
        "counterexample": "Brightness provides unusually strong contrary evidence: its recorded suite exercises retained threshold drafts, pointer and keyboard interruption of easing, immediate low-power updates, unavailable hardware, partial setup failure and focus return to the previous application; its screenshots remain compact and readable.",
        "uncertainty": "Every supplied r1 screenshot was opened. The brief's source path is missing; actual source was located at /tmp/nuguland-zen-int/quickshell/nuguland, identified by the r1 media and noko command.json cwd and overlay-source records. Existing runner logs and selected assertions were read, not rerun; current source was not hash-pinned to capture time. Nulls preserve unverified behavioral, contrast, resource-cost and frame-coverage requirements; 1280×720 renders do not establish both required resolutions and orientations. Feature scores exclude shared deductions. Precedence conflicts retained for owner resolution: system explicitly requires metrics/processes before issues and the arrrgh action; connectivity explicitly restricts passphrase lifetime; calendar explicitly permits its 15-minute background refresh. No clipping finding is inferred from scrollable partial rows."
      }
    }
  },
  {
    "model": "claude-opus-5-5",
    "tool": "pipi_output",
    "args": {
      "output": {
        "features": [
          {
            "name": "bar",
            "scores": [
              2,
              null,
              2,
              1,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              null,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              1,
              2
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 14,
                "severity": "major",
                "evidence": "power-battery-low.png, system-chip-dot.png vs idle-awake.png (media/notify dots); Bar.qml activeDot uses chip.roleColor only",
                "problem": "In the horizontal bar, warning (yellow dot on power/system/tray) and routine activity (pink dot on media/notify/clip) are told apart only by dot colour; the label stays the same and the warning name shows only in the hover tooltip.",
                "fix": "Give attention dots a second cue, either a shape (ring or '!' badge, as the vertical bar already uses badges) or the barTitle word, so warning differs from activity without relying on colour."
              },
              {
                "principle": 4,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "shell-loaded.png chips 'bright', 'clip', 'notify', 'launch', 'noko!'",
                "problem": "Horizontal chip labels are cut-down words or verbs ('bright', 'clip', 'notify') on chips that open surfaces, and punctuation is used as state ('noko!').",
                "fix": "Use short plain nouns (brightness or light, clipboard, alerts) and keep attention on the badge or strong emphasis instead of punctuation in the label."
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "clock",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2
            ],
            "issues": []
          },
          {
            "name": "launcher",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": []
          },
          {
            "name": "media",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              1,
              1,
              null,
              null,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 6,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "no forceActiveFocus in features/media; media-capabilities.png",
                "problem": "Opening media leaves focus on the card, not on play/pause (see shared initial-focus issue).",
                "fix": "Focus the play/pause control on open."
              },
              {
                "principle": 7,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "media-capabilities.png tooltip 'next track unavailable for this player'; PopupButton activeFocusOnTab: interactive && enabled",
                "problem": "Why a transport button is unavailable is shown only in a hover tooltip, and disabled buttons are skipped by Tab, so keyboard users never learn the reason.",
                "fix": "Show one short line under the transport row (for example 'this player only supports play') whenever any control is unavailable."
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "noko",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              1,
              1,
              2,
              1,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              1,
              2,
              2
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 3,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "noko-open.png, noko-history.png idle grey waveform card",
                "problem": "While idle, a full card shows a static fake waveform that carries no state.",
                "fix": "Hide the waveform card while idle, or fold it into the start capture button, and show it only while capturing or transcribing."
              },
              {
                "principle": 4,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "noko-open.png transcript meta '2s'",
                "problem": "Transcript rows show a bare '2s' that can be read as either an age or a duration.",
                "fix": "Label it, for example '2 s long' or '2 s ago', matching whatever it measures."
              },
              {
                "principle": 6,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "noko suite.mjs:42-51 reaches controls only by Tab; no initial focus",
                "problem": "Open does not focus 'start capture' (see shared initial-focus issue).",
                "fix": "Focus 'start capture', or 'install setup' when setup is needed, on open."
              },
              {
                "principle": 13,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "noko-history.png focused 'copy' on synthetic capture 8, row cut at the bottom",
                "problem": "Keyboard reveal scrolls only the copy button into view, so the focused row's text and meta are clipped.",
                "fix": "Reveal the whole row card (Util.revealIn on the row) when its copy button gains focus."
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "system",
            "scores": [
              2,
              1,
              1,
              1,
              2,
              1,
              1,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              1,
              2
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 2,
                "severity": "major",
                "evidence": "system-populated.png, system-machine.png: 'needs attention' sits below six metric rows and is pushed off-screen when machine is expanded",
                "problem": "The popup's real task, what needs me, comes after live metrics instead of leading.",
                "fix": "Put the needs attention band first (or 'disk · memory · battery · updates ok' when clear), then live metrics, then the machine disclosure."
              },
              {
                "principle": 3,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "shell-system.png, system-populated.png accent bars on every metric, near-empty sparklines",
                "problem": "Accent-coloured bars and mostly empty sparklines decorate routine metrics that need no attention.",
                "fix": "Draw routine bars in a neutral tone and reserve accent or warning for thresholds; hide sparklines until they have enough samples."
              },
              {
                "principle": 4,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "system-incidents.png '4 crashes · latest sigsegv · pid 200', 'oom kills'; shell-system.png 'temp n/a'",
                "problem": "Jargon and abbreviations (sigsegv, pid, oom, n/a) replace plain words; 'arrrgh' is spec-mandated (conflict reported).",
                "fix": "Use 'crashed', 'out of memory', and 'no sensor', and move the signal and pid behind the incident disclosure."
              },
              {
                "principle": 6,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "system suite.mjs:52 'Tab reaches the agent action after open'",
                "problem": "Open does not focus the first attention action (see shared initial-focus issue).",
                "fix": "Focus the first needs-attention action, or the machine disclosure when all is clear."
              },
              {
                "principle": 7,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "SystemPanel.qml:303-312; system-*.png white 'i' button",
                "problem": "The 'incident coverage' button does nothing when clicked; its explanation is only in a hover or focus tooltip, and it is drawn as a loud white disc.",
                "fix": "Turn the coverage note into a muted meta line under incident history, or a real disclosure, and drop the fake button."
              },
              {
                "principle": 14,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "system-incidents.png same warning triangle in red, yellow and blue cards",
                "problem": "Error, warning and info severity use one triangle icon, so only colour tells them apart.",
                "fix": "Use distinct glyphs per severity (error circle, warning triangle, info dot) or a severity word."
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "clipboard",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              1,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 11,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "shell-clipboard.png 'clipboard is empty'; clipboard-no-matches.png 'no matches'",
                "problem": "Empty and no-match states are bare words with no next step or 'clear search' action, unlike the launcher and vault.",
                "fix": "Reuse the launcher empty state: 'nothing copied yet · copied text appears here', and 'no items match \"…\"' with a clear search button."
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "vault",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              1,
              1,
              2,
              2,
              2
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 11,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "vault-empty.png: list pane blank, 'no matching items' in the detail pane",
                "problem": "With no matches the results pane becomes an empty hole while the message appears in the detail pane.",
                "fix": "Render the no-match state and clear search inside the list pane where results belong."
              },
              {
                "principle": 12,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "vault-no-items.png magnifier icon for 'vault is empty'; vault-setup.png large 'configure vault' heading vs clock-setup.png 'connect calendar' meta label",
                "problem": "A search icon stands for an empty vault, and the setup heading uses a different type scale from other setup forms.",
                "fix": "Use the vault or lock glyph for the empty vault, and share one setup heading style across clock and vault."
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "audio",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              1,
              1,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 7,
                "severity": "major",
                "evidence": "audio-keyboard-scroll.png tooltip 'show device options'; AudioPanel.qml:105-117,176-206",
                "problem": "Mute and set default are hidden until the row card is clicked; there is no chevron or other visible affordance, only a hover tooltip.",
                "fix": "Show a mute icon button on each row (the speaker glyph) and a visible chevron for the remaining options."
              },
              {
                "principle": 6,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "no initial focus in AudioPanel.qml; suite.mjs:44-51 reaches controls only by traversal",
                "problem": "Open does not focus the default device's volume slider (see shared initial-focus issue).",
                "fix": "Focus the default output slider on open."
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "brightness",
            "scores": [
              2,
              1,
              2,
              1,
              2,
              1,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 2,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "brightness-laptop.png, brightness-live.png: master slider, presets, and one display slider all control the same single display",
                "problem": "With one display, two sliders control the same value, which doubles the controls for one task.",
                "fix": "Hide the per-display row when only one controllable display exists, or hide the master slider."
              },
              {
                "principle": 4,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "brightness-ready-expanded.png 'preflight: done … verification: done'; brightness-docked.png 'hdmi-a-1'; shell-brightness.png 'winit · winit'; brightness-threshold-editor.png 'sunlight from … now 50'",
                "problem": "A technical step log, connector ids, repeated names and cryptic threshold wording leak into the panel ('setup ddc' itself is spec-mandated).",
                "fix": "Collapse the log to one line ('displays ready') with failures only, de-duplicate name and model, and word the editor as 'sunlight above [n] lux · now 50'."
              },
              {
                "principle": 6,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "brightness suite.mjs:48-56 focusControl tabs until reached",
                "problem": "Open does not focus the master slider (see shared initial-focus issue).",
                "fix": "Focus the master slider, or 'setup ddc' when setup is needed, on open."
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "connectivity",
            "scores": [
              1,
              2,
              1,
              1,
              0,
              1,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 5,
                "severity": "blocker",
                "evidence": "Network.qml:50 offline = !deviceAvailable || !wifiEnabled || not station-connected; shell-connectivity.png and shell-loaded.png strong 'network' with no Wi‑Fi device; no ethernet handling in features/connectivity",
                "problem": "'network offline' means 'no Wi‑Fi joined', so a working wired connection is reported as offline and the panel advises plugging in a wireless adapter.",
                "fix": "Derive offline from real connectivity (wired or Wi‑Fi link, for example through NetworkManager or systemd-networkd state), and say 'wired · connected' when there is no Wi‑Fi."
              },
              {
                "principle": 1,
                "severity": "major",
                "evidence": "shell-*.png network chip strong in every production capture",
                "problem": "On wired hosts the chip carries permanent strong emphasis, which trains the eye to ignore real attention.",
                "fix": "Use strong emphasis only when no link of any kind is up (follows from the principle 5 fix)."
              },
              {
                "principle": 3,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "connectivity-bluetooth-devices.png column headers 'device trust state battery actions'; accent-coloured download rate",
                "problem": "A table header for one or two rows, plus an accent on routine throughput, adds chrome without state.",
                "fix": "Drop the column headers (the pills already carry the words) and draw throughput neutral."
              },
              {
                "principle": 4,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "connectivity-masked-update.png '-48 dBm'",
                "problem": "Raw dBm is shown next to the plain 'strong signal'.",
                "fix": "Remove the dBm line or move it behind a details disclosure."
              },
              {
                "principle": 6,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "no initial focus in ConnectivityPanel.qml",
                "problem": "Open does not focus the connected network or the wireless toggle (see shared initial-focus issue).",
                "fix": "Focus the first network row, or the 'turn on' action when wireless is off."
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "power",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              1,
              2,
              1,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              1,
              2,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 4,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "power-armed.png '3 hours · health 94%'; power-desktop.png label 'reboot' vs tooltip 'restart the computer', label 'sleep' vs tooltip 'suspend the computer'",
                "problem": "The time remaining lacks 'left', and labels and tooltips use different words for the same action.",
                "fix": "Write '3 hours left', and make each tooltip use its label's verb ('reboot the computer', 'sleep now')."
              },
              {
                "principle": 6,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "power suite.mjs:63 'Tab reaches logout'; PowerPanel.qml focus only on arrows or restore",
                "problem": "Open does not focus the first action (see shared initial-focus issue).",
                "fix": "Focus 'lock' on open."
              },
              {
                "principle": 12,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "power-compact.png: top row tiles have backgrounds, bottom row (logout, reboot, power off) has none",
                "problem": "The destructive row is set apart by missing the tile background, so its targets look like a different control.",
                "fix": "Give every action the same tile, and mark danger only through the armed state and the destructive role colour."
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "notifications",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              1,
              1,
              1,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 7,
                "severity": "major",
                "evidence": "notifications-history.png reply field without a send control; NotificationCard.qml:206-215 sends only on accepted",
                "problem": "An inline reply can be sent only with Enter; pointer users have no send action.",
                "fix": "Add an icon-only send button (tooltip 'send reply') at the end of the reply field."
              },
              {
                "principle": 5,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "notifications-reply-retry.png 'reply not sent'",
                "problem": "The failure names the problem but no next step.",
                "fix": "Say 'reply not sent · press enter to retry', or pair it with the send button."
              },
              {
                "principle": 6,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "suite.mjs:28 'pointer focuses the reply editor'; no initial focus",
                "problem": "Open does not focus the newest notification or its reply (see shared initial-focus issue).",
                "fix": "Focus the newest card's first action, or 'do not disturb' when empty."
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "tray",
            "scores": [
              2,
              2,
              2,
              1,
              2,
              1,
              2,
              null,
              null,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 4,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "tray-keyboard.png tooltip 'menu for fixture tray (right click)'",
                "problem": "The tooltip is long, uses a parenthetical, and mentions pointer jargon.",
                "fix": "Use 'open menu' as the tooltip and keep the app name in the accessible name."
              },
              {
                "principle": 6,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "tray suite.mjs:41 focus only after pointer activation",
                "problem": "Open does not focus the first item's primary action (see shared initial-focus issue).",
                "fix": "Focus the first attention item's primary action on open."
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "osd",
            "scores": [
              null,
              2,
              2,
              1,
              2,
              null,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 4,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "osd-unknown-event.png 'error / unknown'; osd.js:7-10 unsupported events render as error",
                "problem": "An unsupported event shows a generic 'error' title with the caller's raw text, which tells the user nothing.",
                "fix": "Drop unsupported events from the OSD (log them through diagnostics), and give real errors a specific title such as 'screenshot failed'."
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "privilege",
            "scores": [
              null,
              2,
              1,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              1,
              2,
              2,
              null
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 3,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "privilege-authorized.png 'authorization granted' title plus '✓ authorized' pill",
                "problem": "The success state says the same thing twice and adds a teal accent block.",
                "fix": "Keep one line ('✓ authorized') or close directly on success."
              },
              {
                "principle": 12,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "privilege-initial.png 48 px field with grey border vs vault-locked.png and clock-setup.png 34 px fields with teal focus border",
                "problem": "The prompt's secret field and focus treatment differ from the shared PopupTextField.",
                "fix": "Use PopupTextField (masked, with reveal) and its focus border in PrivilegeSurface."
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "screenshots",
            "scores": [
              null,
              null,
              null,
              2,
              1,
              null,
              null,
              null,
              null,
              2,
              null,
              null,
              null,
              null,
              2
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 5,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "Screenshots.qml capture(): 'unsupported' / 'invalid-path' / 'unavailable' only returned as IPC JSON",
                "problem": "Immediate capture failures produce no visible state; only the unconfirmed timeout reaches the user.",
                "fix": "Route every non-pending status to the same error OSD with the problem and next step, as reportUnconfirmed does."
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "name": "shared",
            "scores": [
              null,
              null,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              1,
              2,
              2,
              2,
              null,
              null,
              1,
              1,
              2,
              2
            ],
            "issues": [
              {
                "principle": 6,
                "severity": "major",
                "evidence": "grep forceActiveFocus: only launcher, clipboard, vault, clock setup and privilege focus a control; PopoutHost.qml:207-212 focuses the card; ux-repair.md 'Each task defines initial focus'",
                "problem": "Non-search popups (media, noko, system, audio, brightness, connectivity, notifications, tray, power) open with focus on the bare card, so Enter and Space do nothing until Tab.",
                "fix": "Let FeatureEntry declare a primary control (or have the panel expose primaryFocus()), and have PopoutHost focus it after open."
              },
              {
                "principle": 12,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "brightness-*.png 'brightness', notifications-history.png 'notifications · 1', noko-open.png 'noko' vs untitled launcher, media, clipboard and audio; vault-setup.png heading vs clock-setup.png",
                "problem": "Some panels repeat the chip name as a title while others have none, and setup headings use different type scales.",
                "fix": "Drop titles that repeat the chip, keeping only status text (for example the unread count), and use one heading style for setup forms."
              },
              {
                "principle": 13,
                "severity": "minor",
                "evidence": "Registry.qml fixed width/height per entry; clock-setup.png, media-capabilities.png, audio-drag-update.png, tray-populated.png, connectivity-open.png, notifications-history.png large blank lower halves",
                "problem": "Popups keep fixed registry heights, so short content floats in large empty cards.",
                "fix": "Let the host take the panel's implicitHeight, capped by the registry height and the output, and keep the fixed height only as a maximum."
              }
            ]
          }
        ],
        "counterexample": "The connectivity blocker assumes a wired host; if the owner only ever uses Wi‑Fi through iwd, 'offline = no Wi‑Fi joined' is true for them, and the strong network chip in the shell-* captures comes only from the nested environment having no iwd device. In that case connectivity principle 5 would be 1 (no wired awareness) rather than 0.",
        "uncertainty": "Toasts, tray menus and the screenshot history were never rendered (the screenshots captures are only fixture readouts), so notifications principle 10 and most screenshots principles rest on source alone. No capture is at 1366×768 or 2560×1440, so principle 13 is judged at 1280×720 only. Contrast was not measured, for example the dim device names in power-devices.png. The initial-focus rule is lowered on every affected feature, which is a judgement call. Spec-mandated labels ('arrrgh', 'setup ddc', the calendar's 15-minute refresh) were not penalised and are listed as conflicts."
      }
    }
  }
]